Routes through the courseSix lessons on the three costs of a trade and how account type and holding period change them.
Stop losing money to spreads and swaps
Lessons on this route
6 lessons
- 1 · Lesson 1.5
The three costs: spread, commission, swap
You pay the spread on entry, commission on some account types, and swap for every night a position stays open. All three are known before you trade.
- 2 · Lesson 1.6
Overnight swap and swap-free accounts
Swap is the daily cost of holding a leveraged position. A swap-free account removes it and usually replaces it with another charge.
- 3 · Lesson 1.13
Account types: standard, raw spread, cent
The same trade costs different amounts on different account types. Raw spread accounts move the cost into commission rather than removing it.
- 4 · Lesson 2.11
Scalping: why costs decide the outcome
At a few pips per trade, the spread and commission are most of the result. The lesson is the arithmetic, before the technique.
- 5 · Lesson 2.13
Swing and position trading
Holding for days or weeks moves the cost from spread to swap and the risk from one session to overnight gaps.
- 6 · Lesson 2.14
Sessions, news and the calendar
Which hours a pair actually moves in, and which scheduled releases widen spreads enough to matter to a stop.
Compare two accounts before you trade
Two readers open the same EUR/USD trade at 1.0850. The first uses a standard account with a spread of 1.2 pips and no commission. The second uses a raw-spread account with a spread of 0.2 pips and a commission of KSh 300 per lot. On one standard lot, one pip is about KSh 1,085. The first pays KSh 1,302 in spread. The second pays KSh 217 in spread plus KSh 300 in commission, which is KSh 517. The raw-spread account costs less on this single trade.
Now hold that trade overnight. The standard account charges a swap of KSh 150. The raw-spread account charges KSh 150 as well, because swap depends on the instrument and the direction, not on the account type. The first reader pays KSh 1,452 in total. The second pays KSh 667. The gap is KSh 785 on one trade. Over twenty trades in a month, that gap becomes KSh 15,700 if nothing else changes. Costs decide the outcome before the market does.
The mistake is choosing an account by the spread alone. A raw-spread account with a high commission can cost more than a standard account if you trade small sizes. A cent account lets you trade in smaller units, so the same pip value falls. Read the cost sheet of each account type and compute the total for your own trade size. The broker sets these numbers, so they vary between brokers and between account types.
Plan the holding period before you enter
Scalping means many trades in one session. Each trade pays the spread and the commission. If your average win is 3 pips and your total cost is 1.4 pips, you keep 1.6 pips before tax. If your cost rises to 2.0 pips, you keep 1.0 pip. The same win rate now produces a smaller result. A strategy that works on a raw-spread account may fail on a standard account because the cost per trade is higher. Compute your break-even pip distance first: total cost divided by pip value.
Swing trading holds a position for days. The swap is charged each night. If the swap is KSh 150 per night and you hold for five nights, that is KSh 750. A swap-free account removes this charge, but it may add a fixed administration fee or a wider spread. Compare the two: KSh 750 in swap against a wider spread of 0.5 pips on one lot, which is about KSh 542. The cheaper option depends on how long you hold. Check the swap-free terms with your broker, because they vary.
Position trading holds for weeks or months. The swap becomes the main cost, and the spread becomes small in comparison. A trade held for thirty nights at KSh 150 per night pays KSh 4,500 in swap. If the position moves 200 pips in your favour, that is about KSh 217,000 on one lot, so the swap is a small part. If it moves 20 pips, the swap is larger than the gain. Decide the holding period before you enter, then pick the account type that matches it.
Match the session to the cost you can carry
The spread on EUR/USD is not fixed. It is usually tighter when many participants are active and wider when few are. The London session and the New York session overlap for a few hours, and that is often when the spread is at its lowest. The Asian session is often quieter, and the spread can be wider. If you trade during a quiet period, your cost per trade rises. Check the live spread on your platform before you enter, not the advertised minimum.
News events move the price quickly. A spread that is normally 0.2 pips can widen to 2 pips or more around a major release. A stop-loss order may be filled at a worse price than you set, because the price jumps. This is slippage, and it adds to your cost. The economic calendar lists these events in advance. If you hold a position through a release, you accept the wider spread and the slippage. If you close before the release, you pay the spread once and avoid the jump.
The calendar also shows when swaps are charged. Some brokers charge three nights of swap on one day of the week to cover the weekend. That day varies between brokers, so read your broker's contract specifications. A trade held over that day pays three times the nightly swap. If you plan to hold for a week, check which day carries the triple charge. Avoiding that one day can cut your swap cost by more than half.
Doing it once, step by step
Work through these steps in order, using your own account numbers and the current EUR/USD price. Do not place a live trade until you have completed all six.
- 01
List the three costs for your account
Open your broker's cost page and write down the spread for EUR/USD, the commission per lot, and the swap per night for a long and a short position. If you use a cent account, note the pip value in KSh. These are the only numbers you need for the rest of the route.
- 02
Compute the cost of one trade
Multiply the spread by the pip value in KSh. Add the commission. That is your cost before swap. For example, a 1.2 pip spread on one standard lot at 1.0850 is about KSh 1,302. Write this figure beside your account type.
- 03
Add the swap for your holding period
Decide how many nights you expect to hold. Multiply the nightly swap by that number. Add it to the cost from step two. If you plan to scalp, the swap is zero because you close before the daily cut-off. If you plan to swing, the swap is part of the cost.
- 04
Compare a swap-free account
Ask your broker for the swap-free terms. Note any administration fee or wider spread. Compute the cost of the same trade on that account. Compare it with the swap-paying account for your holding period. Choose the lower total for the period you actually trade.
- 05
Check the calendar for the triple swap day
Find the day your broker charges three nights of swap. Mark it on your calendar. If you hold a position over that day, add two extra nights of swap to your cost estimate. This is a fixed cost you can plan around.
- 06
Set a minimum win distance
Divide your total cost per trade by the pip value. That is your break-even distance in pips. For a cost of KSh 517 and a pip value of KSh 1,085, the break-even is about 0.48 pips. Your average win must be larger than this distance for the strategy to cover its costs. Write the number down and check it against your trade history.
Questions that come up next
Which account type should I open first if I am not sure how long I will hold a position?
Start with the account type that makes your smallest realistic trade size cheap, not the one with the lowest advertised spread. A raw-spread account adds a commission per lot, so it only wins when your trade size is large enough for the spread saving to cover that commission. A cent account lets you trade smaller units, which lowers the pip value and the total cost of each trade. Compute the total for your own size before you choose. These numbers are set by the broker, so they vary between brokers and account types.
How do I know whether a swap-free account is cheaper for me?
Work out the swap you would pay over your expected holding period, then compare it with whatever the swap-free account charges instead. That alternative is usually a wider spread or a fixed administration fee, and the terms vary between brokers. If you hold for one night, the swap is small and the wider spread may cost more. If you hold for five nights, the swap often becomes the larger figure. Ask the broker for the exact swap-free terms in writing before you decide.
Does a lower spread always mean a lower cost?
No. The spread is only one of the three costs. Commission is charged separately on many raw-spread accounts, and swap is charged on positions held overnight. A low spread with a high commission can cost more than a standard account when your trade size is small. Add all three figures for your own trade size and holding period. Only that total tells you which account is cheaper for you.
How do I calculate the pip value for the size I actually trade?
One standard lot on EUR/USD is about KSh 1,085 per pip at a rate near 1.0850. A mini lot is one tenth of that, a micro lot one hundredth, and a cent account lets you go smaller still. Multiply the pip value by the number of pips your cost adds up to. That gives the cost of the trade in shillings. Do this before you enter, not after.
What should I check before I hold a position over the weekend?
Check the swap charged for each night, including the triple charge that many brokers apply on one weekday. Check whether a scheduled news release falls before the market reopens, because the calendar is free to read and the gap it can cause is not. Then decide whether the expected move is worth the swap you will pay while the market is closed. If it is not, closing before the weekend is the cheaper choice. Swap schedules vary between brokers, so read your own.
Can I compare costs across brokers without opening an account with each one?
Yes. Every broker publishes a cost sheet or contract specification showing the spread, the commission per lot and the swap rates for each instrument and account type. Read those documents and compute the total for a trade size you would really use. Do not rely on an advertised spread alone, because it is often the best case rather than the typical one. The figures differ between brokers, so compare the actual numbers rather than the labels.
The words used on this page
- spread
- The gap between the price at which you can buy and the price at which you can sell. You pay it on every trade, whether you win or lose. On EUR/USD at 1.0850, a spread of 1.2 pips is about KSh 1,302 on one standard lot.
- swap
- A charge applied when you hold a position past the daily cut-off, usually called the overnight charge. It depends on the instrument and the direction of your trade, not on the account type. It is charged again for each night you hold.
- commission
- A separate fee some accounts charge per lot traded, on top of the spread. A raw-spread account usually has a narrow spread and a commission, while a standard account usually has a wider spread and no commission. Compare the total, not either figure alone.
- pip value
- What one pip of movement is worth in shillings for the size you are trading. On EUR/USD at 1.0850, one standard lot gives roughly KSh 1,085 per pip. Smaller sizes give proportionally smaller values.
- break-even pip distance
- The number of pips a trade must move in your favour just to cover its costs. Divide your total cost by the pip value to find it. If your average win is smaller than this distance, the strategy loses before the market is considered.
- swap-free account
- An account that does not charge the overnight swap. It usually replaces that charge with a wider spread or a fixed administration fee. Whether it costs less depends on how long you hold and on the broker's terms, which vary.
What to take away
- Add the spread, the commission and the swap before you judge an account, because the cheapest spread is not always the cheapest trade.
- Compute the total for your own trade size and holding period, since the broker sets these figures and they vary between brokers and account types.
- Match the account type and the holding period to each other, then check the economic calendar before you decide to hold through a news release.